Dutch Oven Brisket – Brasato Al Barolo

Brasato Al Barolo is Italian braised beef in Barolo wine.  The beef – brisket – is braised in a Dutch oven until it is perfectly tender.  Barolo is super expensive so I came up with a more economical dish.  It’s just as good and can be made at a fraction of the cost!

During the winter we eat a lot of pasta, hearty stews and braised meats such as this one.  This dish is essentially Italian pot roast.

What Is Brasato Al Barolo?

Brasato al barolo (I also refer to this as Dutch Oven Brisket even though that is not the proper translation) is beef, typically a chuck roast or some other roast variety, braised in Barolo wine.  The cut of beef is marinated overnight in the wine along with vegetables, herbs, and a few spices.  Cloves, juniper berries, and cinnamon are some of the more common ingredients that can be found in this Italian braised beef.

The next day the beef is seared, then braised for a few hours.  The gravy is then made with the braising liquid and softened vegetables.  Brasato al barolo is traditionally served with polenta, but is quite delicious with creamy mashed potatoes as well.

I tend not to be dogmatic when it comes to recipes.  Eat what you like!  Serve it with what you like, and as I did, braise it in the red wine that you like.

Maybe barolo is a lot cheaper in Italy, but it’s crazy expensive anywhere I see it.  It is always on the top of the best Italian red wine lists.  I have had it a few times and though it’s really good I wouldn’t want to use it for braising.

Valpolicella is an excellent choice because of the price and quality of it.  What I recommend doing is buying a $10-$15 valpolicella for the braising and a valpolicella ripasso for the meal.  Way cheaper than buying 2 bottles of barolo!

Ingredients For Dutch Oven Braised Brisket:

1. brisket – I like this cut of meat over chuck roast because it gives a nicer presentation and doesn’t take quite as long to braise.
2. bottle of red wine – Valpolicella is recommended based on price/quality.  Buy a good quality wine that you actually like to drink.  Do not use old red wine that has been opened.
3. 1 cup low sodium beef broth
4. 3 ounces cognac – used at the end to finish the sauce.
5. 1 onion – quartered
6. 2 large carrots – chopped coarsely
7. 4 cloves garlic – chopped
8. 3 bay leaves
9. 15 sage leaves
10. 10 sprigs thyme
11. 3 rosemary sprigs
12. 10 juniper berries, 5 cloves, salt, pepper
13. ¼ cup olive oil
14. butter and cornstarch – to thicken the sauce at the end if you want.

Dutch Oven Brisket Instructions:

1. Picture of ingredients.
2. 2 briskets with a combined weight of 4 pounds.  Shoot for about 3-4 pounds and if you can, get one flat cut brisket as apposed to 2 like I bought.
3. Rough chop the onion, carrots, and garlic.
4. Place the brisket in a dutch oven and add the whole bottle of wine and the beef broth.  Add the juniper berries, clove, garlic, onions, carrots, and all the herbs.  Try to keep the brisket submerged.   Cover the brisket and refrigerate overnight.  If you can, turn the brisket every few hours to achieve even marination.

5. After marinating for hopefully at least 12 hours, remove brisket and dry off really well with paper towels.  Strain the vegetables from the wine.
6. Season the dry brisket on all sides aggressively with kosher salt and a moderate amount of pepper.
7. Heat dutch oven on medium-high heat with the ¼ cup of olive oil.  Brown the brisket, fat side first, and then on all sides until nice and brown.  Should take about 20-25 minutes.
8. Set brisket aside and brown the veggies in the oil and fat mixture for 10 -15 minutes on medium heat.

9. Add the wine to the pot and, with a wooden spoon, scrape the bottom of the dutch oven to remove all the flavor bits.  Add the brisket to the wine and veggies.
10. Cover and place in 300f oven for 3-4 hours.  Try to turn the brisket every hour or so.  The brisket will take roughly 45-60 minutes per pound to get nice and tender.
11. This is how it will look when it’s done.
12. Remove the brisket to a cutting a board and let it rest covered.

13. Cut the brisket against the grain.  The brisket I used had alternating grain patterns because I had the point.  It’s not worth getting into here, but try to buy a brisket with the grain running in one direction.  If you need more help, check out this post from Hey Grill Hey on how to cut a brisket.
14. The Italian braised beef is ready for the sauce.  Cover it with foil to keep warm.
15. Strain the sauce.  Remove the rosemary and thyme stems, sage, and bay leaves.  Return the veggies to the sauce to make the gravy.
16. To make the gravy, either blend with an immersion or traditional blender.  If using a regular blender be very careful to not overfill when blending hot liquids.
17. Cook the sauce for 20 minutes on high to reduce.  During the last minute, add the cognac.  Turn the heat down and add 2 Tablespoons of butter.  Stir to make a glistening sauce.  Finally if it’s not thick enough for your taste use a little bit of cornstarch mixed with water.  Start with 1 Tbsp of cornstarch to 2 ounces of water, but go easy as too much could ruin it.  I did not use cornstarch.
18. Finally serve the meat with either polenta or mashed potatoes.  Enjoy!

The Italian Pot Roast Is Finished!

I hope these instructions are useful.  They take some time to make, but I think it really tells the story of how to make something that might seem a tad difficult, yet is so worth it!

Some common questions:

What To Serve With Pot Roast Or Brisket?

Brasato al barolo is traditionally served with polenta.  Polenta is real easy to make.  All you do is add the corn meal to boiling water and turn it low, stirring every now and then for 30 minutes to avoid clumps.  Pecorino cheese is excellent in polenta.

Another great option is gorgonzola polenta.  That’s what we had.  The sharp cheese really compliments the red wine sauce in this Italian braised beef recipe.

Garlic mashed potatoes would work well, as would some plain egg noodles.  Basically, make something that can hold the beefy red wine gravy!

A nice loaf of Italian bread is probably a good idea too!

Brisket Substitute?

For this dutch oven brisket, good substitutes would be a a chuck roast or a round roast.  I prefer the brisket flavor over the other two, but they all do really well in the braising liquid.  They are all tough cuts of meat with little fat, which means the longer they cook the more the connective tissue breaks down.  When the tissue adequately breaks down, the meat becomes tender and delicious!

Dutch Oven Brisket Difficulty level:

On a scale of 1-5 with 1 being easy, this dish is a 2.  This recipe is quite easy, the issue is that it takes a lot of time.  But I assure you it’s worth it.

Brasato al Barolo Number 1 Tip:

If you refrigerate the finished product overnight and have it the next day it will be ten times better!  If you’ve ever had leftover pot roast, you know exactly what I’m talking about.  The same phenomenon is observed with chili.  Anyway, it’s still amazing right away, but consider making double so you’ll have an even better one for the next day!

Other Beef Entrees:

• Italian Beef Braciole
• Red Wine Short Ribs
• Reverse Seared Ribeye Steak
• Smoked Chuck Roast Tacos

Drinks:

I recommend a bottle of Valpolicella Ripasso.  They range from $15-$30 and really compliment the flavor of this Italian braised beef.  If you are feeling quite spendy, Amarone is the best that the Valpolicella wines have to offer but is almost as expensive per bottle as barolo.

If you are feeling like a mixed drink check out any of these.

• The Best Negroni
• Blue Cheese Olive Martini
• Perfect Manhattan
• Sparkling Lemon Thyme Cocktail

DID YOU TRY THIS RECIPE?

Give it a star rating.

If you liked this Italian dutch oven brisket recipe we would really appreciate it if you would share it on Instagram or Facebook using #sipandfeast.

We would love to know how you did and it’s nice to show others as well.  Thanks!

Follow us on Instagram, Pinterest, and Facebook.  Sign up to receive great recipe ideas in your inbox.